The end of Becoming Part 2. Buffy is completely shattered at the end, the angel/buffy last scene is heart breaking, and the sarah mclachlan at the end is just perfect.
As much as Fred's death in A Hole In The World makes me tear up (Amy Acker plays it amazingly...), the part that really makes me cry is the very last scene of Shells, where we see Fred leaving home for Los Angeles with the sun lancing through the car's window and her happy hopeful face for the future. It's impossible not to be affected by that.
Fred forgetting who Feigenbaum in A Hole In The World makes me flat out cry.
Watching Wesley in multiple scenes realizing that Fred is gone for good (like the numb scene where he spazzes on Illyria's casket with a crowbar)
The scene in Offspring where Angel and Darla realize that the baby has a heart beat makes me tear up because it's such an emotional scene.
Lullaby. The entire episode makes me bawl. Especially the talk Angel and Darla have and Darla confesses that once the baby is born she won't have a soul and she won't be able to love it, she won't even remember that she loved it, and she wants to remember. This scene just makes me bawl. The depth it gives to Darla's character is amazing, and Julie Benz is amazing.
Sleep Tight. Wes kidnapping Connor and Wes getting his throat slit are hard to watch but the end makes me tear up, where Lilah leaves Angel to suffer.
A New World, when Connor demands to see Angel's other face. This makes me tear up because of how disgusted Connor is, when in the past that same face would calm him when he was distraught.
The end of Benediction makes me cry, when Connor is running back to Holtz's dead body, while Angel read's Holt'z letter. The scene where Justine kills Holtz is also pretty cry worthy, Laurel Hoffman plays it amazingly.
The teaser of Deep Down makes me tear up slightly, just because of how moving the dinner family scene is, followed by the chilling "Freeze the moment Dad".
Supersymmetry. The end of this episode makes me cry, when Gunn is trying to convince Fred to spare Prof. Seidel.
Connor and Cordy having sex in Apocalypse Nowish makes me cry because I end up sticking a fork in my eyes, and the eye is a very sensitive area.
In Release, the touching Watcher/Slayer moment between Faith and Wes, followed by Faith slaying the Wes' bathroom wall.
Connor's monologue in the church in Peace Out makes me tear up because it's so sad and it gives a lot of depth to his character while explaining many of his 'questionable' (ie. terrible) actions.
In Home, Connor finally spilling to Angel the root of his resentment as he says "you let me go". It's so very sad. As is the final family scene with Angel watching through the window and silently saying goodbye to his son.
In Lineage, when Wes has a phonecall to his dad at the end, after unloading a clip into a cyborg who he thought was his father.
Cordelia's goodbye in You're Welcome at the end.
In Origin, the meaningful look Angel shares with Connor at the end before he gets into the elevator after mentioning what he had learned from his father.
Not Fade Away... what can I say? The entire goddamn episode.
In Out Of Mind, Out Of Sight when Marcy starts to disappear in class makes me sad.
When Buffy finds out about her friend's cancer in Lie To Me.
Angelus ripping Buffy apart in the bedroom in Innocence. I love the empty casual way he says "I love you too" before he leaves, it was so much more painful than if he hadn't replied at all. Very nice touch.
Passion. Entire episode.
In I Only Have Eyes For You, the scene between Buffy and Angel where they're both possessed. Insanely good acting.
Kendras death in Becoming Part 1.
The end of Amends.
In Helpless, the look of betrayal on Buffy's face when she finds out about Giles. Also when he cleans her wounds.
In Bad Girls, I don't know why but seeing the VP die is so painful.
The Prom. One word. Awww.
Pangs. I cried through this whole episode cause it was so goddamn funny.
Wild At Heart. Willow + crocodile tears = people melting like ice cream around the world.
New Moon Rising. Whole episode.
Fool For Love, when Buffy throws the money at Spike and tells him he's beneath her. i hate Buffy.
Into The Woods. Riley leaving scene is so sad. Especially the part where you see Buffy running and turning a corner, then cuts to Riley looking out of the helicopter again, and it cuts to a shot of nobody there. So sad.
I forget which episode is Buffy's birthday, I think Bloodties, when Dawn gives Buffy a picture in a frame of a fake memory.
The Body rips me up inside but I can't remember if it makes me cry or not.
Gah... this took a long time to write, and I'm too tired to finish the rest of the seasons. Maybe some other time.
Yes I know, what can I say, I'm very emotional. -.-