Angel after the fall live action or animated

[jdgjordan]

if you could pick would you want to see Angel comics turn into live action show like the original show or it be a animated show

for me i want to see it animated they can do a lot more action and story cost less to make and would not have to worry about actors growing when there supposed to be immortal

[Wyndam]

Well live action definitely, as the show's cancellation still stings.

But being realistic, I would really love to see some animated movies, of Buffy and Angel. There has been a really cool resurgence in animated movies lately, and a lot have been pretty darn good (Wonder Woman, Green Lantern). I'd love to see it happen.

[Hellbound Hyperion]

There's pros and cons to each. Live action would cost more money (regardless of what animation technique is chosen for creating the film via animation, it would probably still cost less than having a dragon for ~40% of the live-action) but would be a nice way to get the cast and crew back together to cap off the story for good.

Biggest setback is Andy Hallett's death - would either have to re-cast Lorne or re-write Lorne's part in the story to be assigned to other characters. Animation, re-casting a voice for Lorne probably wouldn't sting as much if they could get a near-perfect sound-alike, and he could then be brought to life via the animation. (At this point, I must pour some of my drink out on my floor for the fallen Andy. "G'night folks." <3)

So... I'm torn. Either way would be pretty fun though.

[Malsad]

How strange I was thinking about this two days ago, and I would go with animation, it's cheaper, the cast has aged and also have other projects going on curently, so it would be more convenent for them, time wise that is, and it also opens up doors for future Ats/BtVS strait to home movies

[nagpo]

Animated would work out the best. atf, live action would cost millions with all the special effects needed and some actors may not be available for a whole tv show. Some are already on other shows and andy hallet is gone. Having it animated would cost less and requiring the actors to just basically read the lines would be much less time consuming and cost less. you'd only need an andy hallet impersonator(voice wise) and you'd be good.
However, im very picky with animation, most us animators arent that good imo. so i'd say they get Japanese animators to do it. yes, i am an anime freak and i think their cartoons are animated better than ours.

[nagpo]

also, they may want to rewrite some things for lorne if it gets animated. If there ever is a live action angel continuation lorne wont be in it. so, maybe they should get rid of the character somehow. i dont want him dead though.

[The Night Lord]

Live action would be pretty cool, but all the actors are getting on in their age, Andy Hallett is gone and it would just cost too much. Plus, would a studio be interested? Nope. I'd go with animated. Of course, I'd love to see a live action version, but with everyone too busy with their own thing, animation seems the best way to go. Something in the style of Beowulf or Final Fantasty

[VampSlayer]

Live would be best!

But animated would be interesting too.

[angeliclestat]

Actually I would go with animated too. Like Batman:Gotham Knight. Not like the Watchmen motion comic:)

[BlueJay]

I want it animated!

[Hallow Thorn]

I would love live action, but I think that it has been to long for that so animated would work, but only if the art is all like Stephen Mooney work.

[The Night Lord]

Either Stephen Mooney or David Messina's artwork

[Hallow Thorn]

I also think if they do make it animated/ Comic motion they also need to have #23 at the end or work it in some how, They can't just leave Gunn like that if he is still alive.